Let’s kick some butt (in a chill, non aggressive way)
Hey! Thanks so much for being kind about me not posting during the holidays. It really helped be think about what and how to be helpful. I appreciate it a lot and you can expect some new things this year from me. Fingers crossed. I’m going to try to be braver about sharing advice and information and thoughts.
So . . .
Recently, a really popular YouTube author gave out some editing advice. She’s cool. She’s pretty. She’s sarcastic and fun. She’s promoting her own book.
But she also is a little bit wrong this go around because she says the first step in a professional edit is the developmental edit.
It isn’t. Not always.
The first step is often an editorial assessment. Then you revise. Then if you have a butt-ton of money because your daddy is rich and your mother’s good looking, you can hush like a little baby, don’t cry, and get a developmental edit.
Or . . .
You can realize that the first step in a developmental edit is an editorial assessment.
What are these two shiny bits of editing bling?
What is this developmental edit? An editorial assessment?
Let’s use Reedsy’s definitions, okay? Reedsy is a massive platform that connects authors to editors and other freelance professionals and makes sure that those freelancing professionals don’t suck. Full disclosure: I was recruited for Reedsy a couple of years ago and I make money there.
Here’s what that platform (that includes 1 million authors and 2,500 freelancers like me) says about those two styles:
“Editorial Assessment. This is a popular and cost-effective first step for authors, ideal for those at an early stage of their rewrites. Editors offering an editorial assessment will usually:
- Read and analyze your manuscript;
- Provide an evaluation in the format of a report, covering all aspects of the story, structure, and commercial viability;
- Offer suggestions to guide your rewrites.”
And then . . .
“Developmental Editing. A nose-to-tail structural edit of your manuscript for authors who have taken their book as far as they can by themselves. A developmental edit often includes everything in an editorial assessment, plus:
- Detailed recommendations to improve “big picture” concerns like characterization, plot, pacing, setting, etc.;
- Specific guidance on elements of writing craft;
- In-line suggestions and edits in the manuscript.”
So, you could go with a YouTuber’s definition or a platform’s. Totally up to you. But that’s the thing: a lot of people get a lot of money creating edicts for those of us who don’t know better.
- These are the best ways to write.
- These are the worst ways to write.
- These are the best ways to start your story.
- These are the worst ways to start your story.
And it’s all absolutes.
Here’s the thing (and I’m going to sound absolute here):
Art and writing aren’t about absolutes. There is diversity of thought and culture and literature and perception. It shouldn’t all be ‘my way or the highway.’ Your psychographics, your family, your culture, your education, your location, your gender identity, race, religion, all create who you are and your story.
Don’t Lose Yourself
When you’re trying to get published or trying to get a ton of readers, you can sometimes lose yourself and your story in the process of listening to those edicts. Stay true, okay? Learn and grow, but don’t accept absolutely everything that an influencer says as gospel. The world and you and your story is bigger than that.
Because I was just talking about Reedsy, I’m going to take one from there. Thanks, Reedsy!
You can submit your stories at those links as well. And enter a weekly contest.
SUBMISSION POSSIBILITY FOR THIS WEEK
SALT HILL PUBLISHES POETRY, FICTION, TRANSLATIONS, ESSAYS, INTERVIEWS, AND VISUAL ART. Oh my.
“We have two submission periods for fiction and poetry:
December through January
August through September
“We accept nonfiction and art submissions year-round.
“Salt Hill accepts only online submissions via Submittable for poetry, fiction, nonfiction and reviews. For visual art submissions, see below. Most, if not all, of our published work is selected from unsolicited submissions.
“We accept simultaneous submissions, but ask that you alert us as soon as possible if your work is placed elsewhere by either adding a note to your submission through Submittable or withdrawing the full submission.
“We ask that you submit only once per genre per reading period.
“Due to the volume of submissions, we can’t respond individually to submission status queries. We aim to respond to submissions within three to six months.
“Unfortunately, we are not in the position to offer payment to our writers.
“Please submit no more than five poems at a time, in one document.”
“Please do not submit works of more than 30 pages. We accept multiple flash pieces, so long as their combined length does not exceed 30 pages. Please double space, unless the nature of your work requires special formatting.”
“The nonfiction we are interested in pushes the boundaries of the genre, making use of the techniques of fiction and poetry to tell a true story. We want memories, arguments, meditations, revelations, philosophical rants. Salt Hill is a literary journal, so please don’t send us articles or reports. We will consider nonfiction for both our print journal and our website.”
There you go! Let’s go kick some butt in 2023 or make some beautiful music or just really craft our stories the best way we can: piece by piece, word by word, hope by hope.
We’ve got this.
This content and other writing tips, etc. is over here, too.